Removing the wheel/tire can cause issues with ABS sensor gap. BTDT. I know it shouldn't but...... .02 isn't much when it comes to electronics sensitivity.
I've had to adjust the gap on mine a couple if different times after a wheel removal. Either to change the tire or to replace fork seals.
You will want a very clean torx tool to remove the screws, it will help if you soak them with a little penetrating fluid for a bit if you haven't had them out before.
The Clymer lists several BMW part numbers of various shims. Silly question: you used official shims I suppose? I don't have any on hand and would have to order them.
I have never laid a tool on the sensor mounting screws. I have read they are a royal bitch to bust loose.
It appears that your gap is wide.
1st thing I would do is to remove the sensor and shims, and clean the surfaces very very good. There shouldn't be any corrosion build-up, but you never know.
Don't be surprised to find corrosion in the "hole" that the sensor fits into, it will make it hard to remove the sensor. Be patient, be very gentle but firm if you use any tools on the sensor to aid in the removal. The longer you can soak it with penetrating fluid the better so you don't have to get forceful with it.
Yes the screws can be a royal PITA to remove. Have a good sharp(ie clean) torx tool to use on them. I don't think there is one in the factory tool roll, yet some tool rolls will have the feeler gauge for checking the ABS gap(go figure). Be firm but don't break it off either.
I seem to remember the 1st time I did fork seals, when I pulled the forks I wasn't able to get the screws loose so I just disconnected the wire from the loom and left the sensor in the fork body while I worked on it. I have sense been able to get the screws loose and the sensor out, and back in. It can be done, with care.
Get all the surfaces good and clean, re-assemble and check the gap. If it is still wide, I'd then remove the skinniest shim and assemble, check gap... you get the idea.
In my case I was able to remove enough shim to get it to spec. I haven't had to buy any as yet. I do have the shims that I have removed if I ever need them for either bike.