A need to
jam it into fifth gear isn't normal on my moto but one person's
jam might be another's
flip. It's certain that shifting a Brick's gears must always be done assertively. Lack of spline lube tends to show up as stubbornness in
downshifting. The upside of your Brick's condition is that it
does shift into gear and that you
enjoy the agro-mechanical sense of it. Try not to compare your experience to that of others; covet not.
Maybe the previous owner moved the shift lever upwards on the shaft for ergonomic reasons and that change isn't allowing enough throw of the shift lever because your ankle is strained by the time you get to fifth gear. Who knows? Does the shift lever have any rotational play?