For my K75 Frankenbrick I used this stuff. It's 3/16" synthetic rubber with foil. It has an adhesive back so I doubled it up adhesive side to adhesive side.
(http://classickbikes.com/ckb/99_K75F/k75f_build_pics/k75f_796_frankenblanken.jpg)
It's pretty thick so it did take some "coaxing" to get the tank back on but even with that thickness of insulation you can get the tank back on.
(http://classickbikes.com/ckb/99_K75F/k75f_build_pics/k75f_820_frankblank2.jpg)
I call it the "FrankenBlanken." :giggles